TireRack has real world reviews. Both the Pirelli P Zero AS Plus 3 and Conti DWS06are probably the top 2 choices. I think the Pirelli is supposed to be slightly quieter as the tires wear more. Continental occasionally has rebates. I do not recall if Pirelli has them. Pirelli is usually a tiny bit more expensive.
TireRack was bought by Discount tire a while back. There are way more Discount Tire locations. You can go to any local Discount Tire and ask for a price match if you find them cheaper.